audioenhancer Clean a file

DeepFilterNet 3 vs RNNoise: a fan-noise test

Tested October 24, 2026 · RNNoise v0.2 (Xiph.Org, default model) · DeepFilterNet 3 as run by this site

Short answer: on our three fan-noise recordings both models removed the steady fan in the pauses, and automatic transcripts came out almost the same (0, 2 and 1 wrong words out of 92 with DeepFilterNet 3; 1, 3 and 1 with RNNoise). The audible difference is in how they do it: RNNoise switches the sound off completely for 13–21% of the recording, mostly in the pauses, while DeepFilterNet 3 leaves a very quiet, steady background. A 2025 study that tested both found DeepFilterNet 3 ahead on speech quality and intelligibility. RNNoise is about 80 times lighter, which is why it can run inside your browser.

Why it matters: free in-browser tools such as StayPut and Clyper run RNNoise on your own device, so nothing is uploaded. Server tools such as this site and VidClean run DeepFilterNet 3. We make audioenhancer, so we are not neutral: the samples and numbers are below, and you can repeat the test with the open-source programs listed under Method.

Listen: the same 20 seconds through both models

This is the desk-fan clip from our fan-noise page (the speaker's voice was pitch-shifted for privacy). Both results were set to the same loudness. Switch while it plays: playback continues from the same moment.

RNNoise · as in browser tools
DeepFilterNet 3 · this site
RNNoise · as in browser tools
DeepFilterNet 3 · this site
Original, with the fan

Listen for three things: the pauses (silent, or a soft steady background?), the start and end of each sentence (does the noise jump in and out?), and the voice itself (natural, or thin and watery?).

Our measurements on three fan recordings

Three one-take recordings of the same 92-word English script by the same speaker, 42 to 46 seconds each, all made near a running fan. Each was cleaned by both models, then raised back to the original loudness with the same rule this site uses, so neither result looks quieter just because it is softer overall.

Original → DeepFilterNet 3 / RNNoise. For the noise and wrong words, lower is better.
RecordingQuietest 10% of momentsComplete silenceWrong words (of 92)
Take 1 · moderate fan−40 → −91 / silent dBFS2% / 18%0 → 0 / 1
Take 2 · loud fan−26 → −65 / silent dBFS0% / 13%5 → 2 / 3
Take 3 · loud fan−28 → −80 / silent dBFS0% / 21%1 → 1 / 1

What a published study found

Maulana, Akbar and Iklima compared the two models on speech from the JL Corpus mixed with ESC-50 environmental noise (SINERGI 29(2), 2025). With each model's pre-trained weights:

Higher is better. Five synthetic test samples; values from Table 1 and Table 2 of the paper.
ModelSTOI (intelligibility)PESQ (quality)SI-SDR (dB)Processing time per second of audio
Before enhancement0.7271.10−0.9—
DeepFilterNet 30.8101.557.70.081 s
RNNoise0.7431.23−10.60.001 s

The study is small (five samples) and its noise is not fan noise, but it points the same way as the listening test: DeepFilterNet 3 keeps more of the voice, and RNNoise is far cheaper to run.

Which one to use

Questions

Is DeepFilterNet better than RNNoise?

On speech quality, usually yes: in a 2025 study DeepFilterNet 3 scored higher on intelligibility (STOI 0.81 vs 0.74) and quality (PESQ 1.55 vs 1.23). On our three fan recordings both removed the fan in the pauses and transcripts were within one word; RNNoise silenced 13–21% of each recording completely. RNNoise needs about 80 times less computing, so it can run in a browser.

Which noise-removal model do in-browser tools use?

StayPut and Clyper say on their pages that they run RNNoise on your device, so the file is not uploaded. This site and VidClean run DeepFilterNet 3 on their servers.

Can I run this test myself?

Yes. Both models are open source: build RNNoise v0.2 from Xiph.Org and run its demo program on 48 kHz mono audio, and run DeepFilterNet 3 with its deep-filter program. Use the same recording, match the loudness, and listen at the same volume.

Method

Sources